google-site-verification: google4283fb30fde0af74.html
top of page

Fallacy of Fairness

Part I:  Description

What is the Fallacy of Fairness?

The Fallacy of Fairness is a logical error where someone assumes that "fair" always means "exactly equal". This ignores the reality that true fairness often requires considering individual needs, context, and underlying imbalances.


Why the Fallacy of Fairness Matters

This fallacy can lead to:

  • Rigid decision-making: Focusing on superficial equality over addressing the underlying intent of fairness.

  • Resentment: When unequal distribution appears unfair without understanding the rationale.

  • Missed solutions: The drive for "equal" outcomes can obscure more creative and just approaches.


Examples of the Fallacy of Fairness

  • Two children want the same toy. Splitting the time with it "fairly" may ignore the fact that one child is developmentally more interested in it.

  • In a workplace, giving every employee exactly the same raise ignores differences in performance or cost-of-living adjustments.

  • In social justice, "equal treatment" may perpetuate systemic inequalities if it doesn't acknowledge historical disparities in opportunity.


The Fallacy of Fairness is Beyond Simple Equality

True fairness often involves:

  • Equity: Meeting people where they are and providing support based on their individual needs.

  • Context: Considering the bigger picture and the historical or situational factors impacting justice.

  • Compassion: Seeking outcomes that promote individual well-being, not just adherence to abstract rules.

Part II:  Common Questions

What's the difference between fairness and equality?

  • Answer: Fairness is the broader concept about achieving just outcomes for all, which may sometimes involve unequal treatment to achieve that goal. Equality means treating everyone exactly the same, which can be unfair if it doesn't account for individual differences or needs.


Can the Fallacy of Fairness ever be used for good intentions?

  • Answer: Yes! Sometimes people default to "let's split it evenly" with the intention of avoiding favoritism. However, well-meaning attempts at equality can end up causing harm if they ignore deeper needs.


How does the Fallacy of Fairness manifest in social justice discussions?

  • Answer: It can show up with arguments like "All Lives Matter" in response to "Black Lives Matter". This focuses on superficial equality, ignoring the systemic injustices that necessitate emphasizing the disproportionate harm to Black lives.


How can I overcome the Fallacy of Fairness in my own thinking?

  • Answer:

    • Question rigid rules: Ask, why is "equal" the default? Does it address the true goal?

    • Seek multiple perspectives: Consider the situation from different viewpoints to see if "equal" actually leads to a just outcome for everyone.

    • Focus on the intent: Is the goal of fairness to truly benefit people, or to simply avoid accusations of unfairness?


Are there any situations where strict 'equality' actually is the fairest approach?

  • Answer: Yes, sometimes! Dividing resources where everyone has the same stake, or ensuring legal rights apply equally to all citizens are examples where strict equality is indeed crucial for justice.

Part III:  Additional Resources

Books about the Fallacy of Fairness


Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do? by Michael Sandel:

  • A philosophy professor's exploration of different theories of justice, challenging simplistic notions of fairness.


Thinking, Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman:

  • This classic explores cognitive biases, including those that can lead to the Fallacy of Fairness, hindering our ability to reason.


Websites and Articles about the Fallacy of Fairness


  • Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Distributive Justice (https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/justice-distributive/): In-depth discussion on different philosophical approaches to fair resource allocation.


  • Psychology Today: The Fairness Fallacy : Focuses on how this fallacy impacts interpersonal relationships.


  • Effectiviology: Fallacy of Fairness: Offers clear explanations and examples for critical thinking.


Online Resources and Tools about the Fallacy of Fairness


  • The Fallacy Files: List of Fallacies: Comprehensive resource on various logical fallacies, including the Fallacy of Fairness.


  • Your Logical Fallacy Is… (https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/): A fun, interactive website that helps you identify fallacies in arguments


  • OpenIDEO (https://openideo.com/): A platform fostering collaborative solution-finding around social justice issues. Explore case studies where 'equality' alone is insufficient.


Further Exploration about the Fallacy of Fairness


  • YouTube Channels on Social Justice: Search for channels that analyze current events and discuss different perspectives on fairness.

Part IV:  Disclaimer

These results were highly selected, curated, and edited by The Nexus Inititiative. To make this amount of complimentary content available at a cost-effective level for our site visitors and clients, we have to rely on, and use, resources like Google Gemini and other similar services.

bottom of page